I quit design once

The rejections that made me quit were about a year, not about me. I only saw it when the fashion changed.

I quit design once. Every design I showed was rejected, by clients and by project managers, and I decided design was not my thing.

It was the Web 2.0 years, when every site was expected to have gradients and shiny buttons. I liked doing only what was necessary, and my screens showed it.

Before the rejections, I had thought design was something I would never give up. I needed a job, so I moved to front-end development, the code that turns a design into a page, and to search engine optimisation (SEO).

I heard a verdict on me

Each rejection was about a screen. I heard it as a statement about me. After enough of them I could no longer tell the two apart.

My work had a real weakness, but not the one I believed in. I could not explain why less was the right answer. A plain layout had to be argued for, and I did not yet know how to argue it. I had the taste and lacked the words.

The rejections measured fit: between what I made, what people expected that year and how well I could explain the difference. It took a change in fashion for me to see that.

I had handed over the measure

There was a second reason the rejections landed so hard. I was never happy with my own work, so I looked to other people to tell me whether it was good. When approval is the only measure, a run of refusals has nothing to weigh against it.

The people who turned the work down were asking for what every other site had. I was the one who had handed them the job of deciding my worth.

The fashion changed

About two years after I quit, flat, minimal interfaces became the common style. The kind of work I had been turned down for began to look ordinary.

That was when I saw what I had been doing. I had been treating myself as a follower, someone who waited for the fashion to agree with me. I was not one. So I returned to design.

In time my own profile led with the word minimal. That approval depended on the year as much as the rejections had. Gloss was a fashion, and so was the minimalism that replaced it. A fashion on my side proved as little as a fashion against me.

I ask about the project now

I have designed every day since. I am a designer who also writes the code, knows what a layout costs to build and knows how a page gets found. The work I took because I needed a job made me more useful to a team than I had been before I left.

Now I look at the context before the fashion: what the business needs, and where the balance sits between doing too much and too little. Those are questions about the project. The year has less to say about them. I still work to get every pixel right, and to make sure the screen solves the problem it is for.

Work still gets rejected. I take each rejection as a note about the screen, and then I let it go.

The rejections were about a year. I had treated them as being about me.